Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Saturday, 11th October 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Hope fades for climber who went missing in blizzards



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 09 February 2008
HOPE was fading last night for an experienced mountain rescuer missing in blizzard conditions on a notorious Highland range for two nights.
More than 50 colleagues of Pete Grant battled desperately against 90mph winds and driving snow yesterday to search the Achnashellach area in Wester Ross in the hope of finding him alive.

But the hunt was called off last night without success and i
s due to resume again at first light today.

Police are appealing for anyone who may have spoken to Mr Grant on Wednesday or Thursday, and who may have information about his planned route, to contact them.

Mr Grant, 49, a former member of the Kintail Mountain Rescue Team and the Search and Rescue Dogs Association, failed to return from a solo ice climb in the Achnashellach area on Wednesday.

His car was found at a popular walkers' car park at Achnashellach, and there are several hills he may have headed for from that point, including the Five Sisters of Kintail.

Yesterday, his former colleagues were joined in the hunt by members of the Torridon and RAF Kinloss mountain teams and eight search and rescue dogs. A Sea King helicopter from RAF Lossiemouth was scrambled to assist but was grounded for most of the day due to the fierce conditions.

Mr Grant, an experienced rock and ice climber with advanced survival skills, had been expected back at his home in Balmacara, near Kyle of Lochalsh, on Wednesday evening. His son raised the alarm on Thursday when he had failed to return.

One of the rescuers said last night: "He is experienced, but we are concerned because of the weather conditions and he hasn't been seen since Wednesday."

Neil Hinchcliffe, the leader of the Torridon Mountain Rescue Team, said the rescuers had faced winds with average speeds of 60mph, but gusting to 90mph, and poor visibility "Because of the conditions, we had difficulty in progressing," he said.

He added that the rescuers had been sweeping a massive area in their search.

"Although he has been missing for quite some time, he is experienced and our fingers are crossed," he said.

Chief Inspector Paul Eddington, of Northern Constabulary, insisted the rescuers remained hopeful. "He has the survival skills and navigational skills to last in the hills," he said.

"But, obviously, as time goes by, then hope does fade."

Mr Grant is 5ft 6in to 5ft 7in tall, of athletic build and clean shaven. When last seen, he was wearing outdoor clothing and carrying a rucksack.





The full article contains 426 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 08 February 2008 10:36 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Walking and climbing
 
1

Ross Fyffe,

Scotland 09/02/2008 02:33:33
irrispossible, I wonder how many times the words came from his mouth, "never go to the hills on your own"
2

Beth Boyle,

Rural, NY 09/02/2008 05:30:50
So why did he not have one of the GPS things with him? What is wrong with people? I feel for his family but honestly this is daft.
3

sergiesmax,

09/02/2008 09:31:34
#1 get a life you have no idea what you are talking about,this man was no idiot he is highly experienced and well trained, and we do not need comments from the likes of you so shut your mouth and go and sit in your chair man.#3GPS is not always reliable but is always a good addition to your kit better with a map and compass which this man probably had.
4

Ross Fyffe,

Scotland 09/02/2008 15:35:18
lets see now zero vis. 90 mph winds, driving snow, let me just get my map out lay it on the ground and take a reading with my compass, ............ now what do i need to take a reading, lets see, a land mark, but zero vis, oh wers my map gone ........ my it is windy ......... OR top of the range GPS switch on, accept 12 sat fixings, lets me know withing 11 feet of where I am.

5

RabtheCairnterrier,

Highlands 09/02/2008 17:57:25
Wherever Mr Grant was heading for it certainly
wasn't the Five Sisters of Kintail which is a long way
south of Achnashellach. A quick glance at a basic road atlas would have told the reporter that, or doesn't the Scotsman's resources stretch that far? Failing that, the fact that the search for Mr Grant, a member of the Kintail Mountain Rescue Team, was being conducted by the Torridon Mountain Rescue Team might have been a clue. This is inexcusably sloppy journalism.
6

Ross Fyffe,

Scotland 09/02/2008 21:01:39
# 9 you can list any amount of www sites you like, and I looked at yours 6 bl**dy years out of date.

I also quote from the same site note the 4th word

Make sure your companions are well-equipped and that everyone knows what the plan for the day is. Don't allow your group to split up and never leave someone on his/her own (if one person turns back alone, the remainder of the group will have to spend the rest of the day worrying about whether the person has made it back OK). Travel at the speed of the slowest or least fit person - pushing someone to go faster will only create problems later in the day when fatigue causes mistakes or slips.

A common contributory cause of accidents is disparity within groups - different aspirations and abilities can lead to poor decision making on the hill. Going into the hills alone is generally more serious than going with a group and requires experience and judgement gained from trips made in the company of others and this is particularly true in winter.

As per for cost of gps, what cost a life ???



7

Ross Fyffe,

Scotland 09/02/2008 22:24:37
quote from above news article


Police are appealing for anyone who may have spoken to Mr Grant on Wednesday or Thursday, and who may have information about his planned route, to contact them.

Quote from mounteneering guide that # 9 was so kind to point out

"that everyone knows what the plan for the day is"

so why are the polis having so much trouble finding the "plan" from an "experienced" mountaineer
8

Jamie Bankhead,

Mountaineering Instructor 10/02/2008 10:13:08
Before you get too locked into a circular argument about navigation in poor visibility and strong winds, it should probably be pointed out that Wednesday was a lovely clear day; albeit with some localised avalanche danger. The subsequent days (when the search was being conducted) were considerably less pleasant.

Portraying Peter as a reckless chance-taker is not only deeply offensive to his greiving family/friends/colleagues (who may well be reading this), but is also innacurate. Can you not understand the urge to be in beautiful, uplifting places? Or the satisfaction to be had from safely negotiating somewhat trickier terrain than your keyboards? It can never be made entirely safe and sanitised, but is that what you want in your lives?

I have often gone out on my own for a day in the hills; this might be seen as a bit deviant and left-of-centre, but is surely infinitly more admirable and life-afirming than insulting the dead.

The teams that searched for and found Peter understood that; they are all mountaineers who have done the same. You won't hear them criticising.
9

Ross Fyffe,

Scotland 10/02/2008 18:42:29
I am ashamed at what I wrote ........ sorry
10

highfifer,

10/02/2008 20:27:39
I hope Mr Grant's family don't read this forum, but if they do - my condolences.

The ill-informed tripe from some people on this site is deeply offensive.

In addition the fact that one of our national newspapers can't even be bothered to get some simple facts straight - 5 Sisters? it would take 2 days to walk to the 5 from Achnashellach.

The Scotsman should consider getting itself a red top - it's dumbing itself down enough, and given the following in its forum, it's already got a red top readership.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.